They are to be given new powers in England in April but as long as they are not doing unannounced visits and allowing staff to present false facades as they did in the case of Argyll and Bute Women’s Aid, they will continue to let people down. A lot of planning went in to ABWA inspection visits and on the surface everything probably looked fine but it wasn’t and even when things did go wrong, the CQC was very limited in what it could actually do despite acknowledging that they had failed me very badly in more ways than they could address. And the CQC NEVER approached the women ABWA was supposed to be caring for to hear their opinion, which borders on the ridiculous. The same applies in every case where support workers are being allowed to pretend that they’re doing the right thing one afternoon a year. It happened when I worked in care too but that’s a story for another day!
Thousands of allegations of abuse and neglect of elderly people were made in England last year, the BBC has learned.
Some 14,888 claims about the welfare of care home residents aged 65 and over in 2013-14 were reported to 74 councils, 5 live Investigates has found.
Relatives say the system designed to handle such complaints is flawed and they often go unheeded.
The body representing senior social services managers says there needs to be more investment in care staff.
Anyone is entitled to raise suspicions about a person’s care, and local authorities are obliged to look at the claims.
If necessary, they launch what is known as a formal safeguarding investigation to decide what action should be taken.
But some families who have raised safeguarding concerns say the system is not working.
Orchid View, which has since reopened under new management, was run by Southern Cross
In West Sussex, 19 people died after suffering “sub-optimal care” at the Orchid View care home in Copthorne.
The problems at Orchid View came to light following a police investigation that started in 2011 – but in a two-year period before that, families and health workers had been raising concerns about the care in the home.
A serious case review into the Orchid View scandal revealed there had been 20 separate safeguarding referrals. The home has since closed.
A number of those concerns were substantiated but it was not until the police inquiry started that the decision was taken to shut the home.
Families want to know why action was not taken sooner given that so many safeguarding investigations had taken place.
Enid Trodden died less than a year after going into the home
Lesley Lincoln said she complained constantly about the care given to her late mother, Enid Trodden.
She says she wrote letters raising concerns to health professionals, the Care Quality Commission and the council’s safeguarding team but she says no-one saw it as a safeguarding issue.
“I felt I was tearing my hair out and nobody was listening,” she said.
“It was only treated as a safeguarding alert after I raised the roof when she went into hospital,” she says.
“It was only after my mother’s death and the inquest, I realised there had been so many (safeguarding) referrals at Orchid View.”
In a statement, West Sussex County Council said: “We take all safeguarding concerns extremely seriously. We are working hard to reduce the likelihood of a repeat ever happening again and this includes work to implement all the recommendations of the serious case review.”
Families ‘not informed’
The Local Government Ombudsman has also investigated cases where families have felt the safeguarding system has not worked.
In one case, the ombudsman found a council was at fault after its safeguarding team asked the home at the centre of an allegation of poor care to conduct its own safeguarding investigation.
In other cases the ombudsman found delays in launching safeguarding inquiries, poor investigations and that families had not been given information.
Seventy-four councils out of 152 responded to the request by 5 live Investigates to state the number of safeguarding referrals they had received for people aged 65 and over in care homes – the first investigation of its kind.
‘Investment in care’
Between them they reported that they had received 14,888 referrals. Of those, 4,523 – about one third – were substantiated. If all the councils approached had provided data, the overall figure would obviously be higher.
David Pearson, president of the Association of Directors of Adult Social Services, said: “Needs are rising as resources are falling. Adult social services have sustained a 26% reduction in funding since 2010.
“Prevention is better than cure and we need to ensure there is sufficient training and investment in care staff.
“It is crucial that we have sufficient social workers working with other professionals to carry out investigations.”
The Department of Health called the abuse and neglect of vulnerable people “deplorable”.
A spokesman said the new Care Act which comes into law in April will give the Care Quality Commission greater powers to prosecute providers and company directors for unacceptable care and introduce new, tougher standards for inspecting care homes.